Top Down Comforter Comparison Guide

Need help choosing a comforter? Ask a bedding nerd!

Just tell me a little more about how you sleep and what you're looking for. For example:

"I'm a hot sleeper who lives in Southern California. I want a blanket that's light and fluffy like a down comforter but I can't stand anything that makes me sweat. Is there a comforter that's under $200 and right for me?"

I will personally go through each of your questions and suggest a couple comforters for you. Be sure to let me know...

  1. When do you want to use your comforter? (summer/winter/all year round)
  2. What size comforter are you looking for? (twin/queen/king/cal-king)
  3. Are you a hot or cold sleeper?
  4. What is your budget? (<$200,<$400,<$1000,$1000+)
  5. What's the most important factor for you? (looks/customer service/warranty/warmth/lightness)
  6. Are you in the USA or overseas?
  7. Any other questions or concerns?

Question

Your Email (so I can send you an answer)


The Best Brands Based On Consumer Ratings & Reviews

The best comforters of 2014 and 2015

Sort the list of comforters by clicking the up/down arrows at the top of the table.

*Prices quoted at the time of publication. Current prices may vary.

NameBrandRating
(5 is best)
Average Price*WarmthCountry of OriginAllergy Safe?True Baffle Boxes?Retailers
AllerRest Down Comforters
Pacific Coast4
$275Year-round
(60F-70F)
Made in USAYesNo

  • Check Prices
  • Classic Down ComfortersPacific Coast4.3$180Year-round
    (60F-70F)
    Made in USAMaybeNo

  • Check Prices
  • Down ThrowsPacific Coast4.5$80Light warmth
    (over 70F)
    Made in USAMaybeNo

  • Check Prices
  • Embrace Down ComforterPacific Coast4.5$330Year-round
    (60F-70F)
    Made in USAMaybeNo

  • Check Prices
  • Luxury Down BlanketPacific Coast4.8$180Light warmth
    (over 70F)
    Made in USAYesNo

  • Check Prices
  • SuperFluff DeluxePacific Coast4.3$450Year-round
    (60F-70F)
    Made in USAYesYes

  • Check Prices
  • Light Warmth Down ComforterPacific Coast4.8$230Light warmth
    (over 70F)
    Made in USAMaybeNo

  • Check Prices
  • Light Warmth Deluxe Down ComforterPacific Coast4.2$350Light warmth
    (over 70F)
    Made in USAMaybeNo

  • Check Prices
  • Premier Down ComforterPacific Coast4.2$250Year-round
    (60F-70F)
    Made in USAMaybeNo

  • Check Prices
  • SuperFluff Down ComforterPacific Coast4.4$275Year-round
    (60F-70F)
    Made in USAMaybeYes

  • Check Prices
  • Ultimate Extra WarmthPacific Coast4.7$450Extra-warmth
    (under 60F)
    Made in USAMaybeYes

  • Check Prices
  • SuperLoft Down BlanketPacific Coast5.0$180Light warmth
    (over 70F)
    Made in USAMaybeNo

  • Check Prices
  • Deluxe Oversized Down ComforterPacific Coast4.8$450Year-round
    (60F-70F)
    Made in USAMaybeYes

  • Check Prices
  • AllerRest Down BlanketPacific Coast4.7$229Light warmth
    (over 70F)
    Made in USAYesNo

  • Check Prices
  • Hotel Collection Down BlanketPacific Coast4.3$230Light warmth
    (over 70F)
    Made in USAMaybeNo

  • Check Prices
  • Down BlanketPacific Coast4.7$180Light warmth
    (over 70F)
    Made in USAMaybeNo

  • Check Prices
  • Luxury Down ComforterPacific Coast4.8$500Year-round
    (60F-70F)
    Made in USAMaybeYes

  • Check Prices
  • Hotel Collection Down ComforterPacific Coast4.5$220Year-round
    (60F-70F)
    Made in USAMaybeNo

  • Check Prices
  • CuddleTop Down ComforterPacific Coast4.4$200Year-round
    (60F-70F)
    Made in USAMaybeYes

  • Check Prices
  • Stratus Down ComforterPacific Coast4.8$450Year-round
    (60F-70F)
    Made in USAMaybeNo

  • Check Prices
  • Lunesse BatistePacific Coast4.8$450Year-round
    (60F-70F)
    Made in USAMaybeNo

  • Check Prices
  • Extra Warmth Down ComforterPacific Coast4.8$330Extra-warmth
    (under 60F)
    Made in USAMaybeNo

  • Check Prices
  • Chezmoi White Goose Down AlternativeChezmoi3$45Year-round
    (60F-70F)
    Made in ChinaYesNo
  • Check Prices
  • Pyrenees White Goose Down ComforterPinzon4.9$220Year-round (60F-70F) and Extra-warmth (under 60F)Made in USA (Covering made in China)MaybeYes
  • Check Prices
  • Aloe Vera Microfiber Anti Allergic Down Alternative ComforterLe Vele3.8$120Year-round
    (60F-70F)
    Made in TurkeyYesNo

  • Shop at Amazon.comCheck Prices


  • Shop at Wayfair.comCheck Prices
  • White Down Alternative ComforterSweet Jojo Designs3.2$60Year-round
    (60F-70F)
    Made in ChinaYesNo

  • Check Prices
  • Meribel Synthetic Fill ComforterCuddledown3.5$220Year-round
    (60F-70F),
    Light Warmth,
    Extra Warmth
    Made in USAYesNo
  • Check Prices

  • 600 Fill Power White Goose Down Striped ComforterCuddledown3.4$400Blanket,
    Summer, Year-round
    (60F-70F),
    Extra warmth,
    4 levels of warmth
    Made in USAYesYes (Levels 3 and 4 only)

  • Check Prices
  • Beyond Down Gel Fiber ComforterSleep Better4.5$150Year-round
    (60F-70F)
    Made in USAYesNo
  • Check Prices
  • 1000TC Hungarian Goose Down ComforterEgyptian Linens4.1$160Extra-warmth
    (under 60F)
    Made in USAMaybeYes
  • Check Prices
  • 500 Thread Count 750 Fill Power Goose Down ComforterRoyal Hotel4.6$200Extra-warmth
    (under 60F)
    Made in ChinaNoYes
  • Check Prices
  • Primaloft Down Alternative ComforterPinzon4.6$115Year-round and
    extra-warmth
    Made in USAYesNo
  • Check Prices
  • Supremium Baffle Box Hungarian Goose Down ComforterWarm Things4.8$401Year-round
    (60F-70F)
    Made in USAMaybeYes
  • Check Prices
  • Hotel White Goose Down ComforterPacific Coast4.3$449Year-round
    (60F-70F)
    Made in USAMaybeNo
  • Check Prices
  • 900 Fill Power Batiste Down ComforterCuddledown4.6$13005 levels of warmth: Summer to Extra WarmMade in USAMaybeYes
  • Check Prices

  • 260 TC California King Oversized White Goose Down Comforter: Summer FillHighland Feather4.8$280SummerMade in USAYesYes
  • Check Prices
  • Icelandic Eiderdown ComforterDaniadown4.9$3800Extra WarmMade in CanadaMaybeYes
  • Check Prices
  • Paradise DuvetDaniadown5$5803 levels of warmth: Summer, 4 Seasons, and WinterMade in CanadaMaybeYes
  • Check Prices
  • Eiderdown European Batiste Down Comforter
    Cuddledown4.6$110006 levels of warmth: Blanket to WinterMade in USAYesYes
  • Check Prices

  •  

    x